Thursday 21 May 2015

A Trip down King Street

[Any of the images can be clicked to enlarge.]

Last month, Highland Cycle Campaign organised a presentation with guest speaker Chris Thompson from Living Streets.

The subject of 20's Plenty was inspired by a recent earlier meeting with Rod King MBE.

As I would be doing an introduction, I decided to familiarise myself with some of the 20 mph streets around Inverness.

There are significant examples of good practice in Inverness but I found one area particularly confusing.

Kenneth Street is on the A82 Trunk Road linking Inverness to Glasgow through Fort William. Kenneth Street is 30 mph but the streets between it and the River Ness are all 20 mph.

The route of interest starts at Junction A.

Junction A

King Street is one-way with its speed limit clearly signed as 20 mph from the junction.

Let's proceed along King Street to the next main crossroad.

Junction B

This is the junction of King Street with Greig Street.

Just before the junction there is a pair of 30 mph signs. On the other side of the junction there is a pair of 20 mph signs.

This would seem to imply that Greig Street, the street we're crossing must be 30 mph.

Junction C

But if we take a short detour to the Kenneth Street end of Greig Street we can see that Greig Street is actually signed (correctly) as 20 mph.

So the 30 mph signs at Junction B are wrong.

Junction D

Continuing a little further along King Street, we come to the junction with Balnain Street.

It is signed as 30 mph from the start but is signed again as 20 mph from half-way along.

The resulting short 30 mph length makes no sense.

Junction E

Next we come to Queen Street which is 20 mph and has 20 mph signs just before it meets Huntly Street.

Huntly Street runs along the west bank of the River Ness and is currently closed for the Flood Alleviation Scheme.

When re-opened it will (still) be 20 mph.

Junction F

At its far end, King Street forks into two streets that both make a junction with Celt Street.

The street on the right, Duff Street, has a pair of 30 mph signs just before Celt Street.

Junction G

The street on the left branch, Muirtown Street, similarly has a pair 30 mph signs where it crosses Celt Street.

But Celt Street is 20 mph.

So the 30 mph signs at Junctions F and G must be wrong.


It seems clear that there are five pairs of 30 mph signs in this area that make no sense and are wrong.

I queried this with Highland Council. The response didn't really anser my question but there was some speculation that it had to do with the Flood Alleviation Scheme. I got no response from FAS at all.

Some people I've spoken to suggest that the signs will be checked and corrected if necessary at the completion of the Flood Alleviation Scheme in this area. I can see no reason to delay the removal of these 30 mph signs.

I appreciate that the current law makes it awkward and costly to create 20 mph zones.
The Highland Council have achieved many good results in difficult circumstances.
But inconsistent signage can cause drivers to lose track of the applicable speed limit.

Updated 31 May 2015

I informed the relevant Councillors of the original blog and got positive responses.
I didn't hear any more about it so I checked again on Sunday 31 May and was pleased to see that all the offending 30 mph signs had been removed. There are now also additional 20 mph signs.

I don't know if the original blog had any effect. The removal may have already been planned.
However the final result is most welcome. A large area is now 20 mph throughout.
All signs are mandatory (not just advisory 20's plenty or time dependent).
This is particularly good because the area contains two primary schools.

Your comments are welcome.

No comments: